|
 
Vedlegg 5 : English summary
EVALUATION OF ENSI 3 IN NORWAY
Participation and EE-project
Norway has participated in the OECD-initiated
environmental education (EE) projects ENSI 1 and ENSI 2. An analysis of
the work done concluded that although EE seemed to be an efficient tool
in school development, the Norwegian Ministry of Education (KUF) lacked
systematic documentation and evaluation of the development and achievements
at school level.
Therefore it was decided to participate in
a further phase: ENSI 3. In this programme, school development was to
be focused on: How to implement EE in order to strengthen school development,
and discover what barriers prevented such a development. The project was
launched in 1998.
ENSI 3:
The EE-project chosen in Norway as compulsory
for all participating schools in this third stage was MEIS (Environment
and Energy in School), a well-known EE-project which many schools have
used for a several years. The project involves pupils monitoring indoor
environmental parameters like CO2-concentration in classrooms, air dust
content, energy consumption, indoor and outdoor temperature. This leads
to a comparison of the various parameters, and a consideration of general
environmental questions like sustainable development, pollution, energy
production and consumption, health etc.
Evaluation
A research group was established and
involved in the programme from late May `99.
The research group's tasks were:
- To evaluate how the ENSI project is being
implemented in the various participating schools
- to assist in the development of a uniform
report form.
- to participate in workshops and meetings
where the intention is to develop a common understanding of goals and
methods connected to this project
- to work out an understanding and analyses
of how co-operation externally and internally in the schools' functions,
and whether EE might be used as a means for school development in this
field.
Research in two stages
The evaluation was split into two stages.
The purpose of research at Stage 1 was:
- to define the situation for the various
schools prior to their involvement
- to discover what has been achieved so
far in the various schools, focusing on changes in school organisation
as a whole, and especially on internal and external co-operation.
- to initiate discussions with the participating
schools in the understanding of the overall aims and problems of the
ENSI project.
Stage 2 will be an in-depth analysis of
the various schools, trying to discover and define barriers, and furthermore
to find different strategies for using EE-projects in mainstreaming school-development
projects.
Methodology
The research group worked out a questionnaire
for headmasters and participating teachers. To be able to formulate this
questionnaire, the researchers analysed the letter of invitation from
the Ministry, which set the goals and contents of the project, and also
visited a few schools to obtain an impression of and to discuss their
understanding of the project.
Later, the researchers participated at a
workshop for headmasters and teachers involved in ENSI. The research-group
has arrived at the conclusion that a relevant description of the methodology
applied, would be "action research".
School participation
The ministry invited 22 schools to participate,
of which 17 still are participating. However, only 13 schools have answered
the questionnaire, mostly due to late active participation. It must also
be added that several of the schools had hardly started when they received
the questionnaire.
Results.
- Conditions at starting point:
- Almost all schools and teachers
had been or were involved in EE-projects, and several of them were
familiar with or already engaged in the MEIS-project.
- Most of the schools and teachers
had experience in including external persons or institutions in
their teaching, and most often in connection with EE-projects.
- The decision to take part in ENSI
was made in several decision-making bodies, in some of which technical
staff, parents and pupils were included.
- Headmasters and teachers often had
different purposes for participating in EE-projects.
- External co-operation within ENSI:
- To a varying degree, external sources/institutions
were contacted in order to strengthen the professional approach
to the project.
- The external sources/institutions
were often approached by headmasters and teachers, but rarely by
pupils.
- A few schools had no experience
in contacting external contacts before ENSI, but did so as a result
of their involvement in ENSI.
- Internal co-operation:
- The technical staff were involved
in the practical tasks (i.e. monitoring of energy use), but seldom
in classroom activities
- There was very little change in
educational methods in classroom activities, although pupils became
more interested in environmental matters.
- The ENSI teachers reported little
change to their educational activities outside the project.
- With the exception of a few schools,
ENSI had no significant effect on teachers outside the ENSI-project.
- Some schools established new decision-making
bodies for co-operation or steering committees with regard to ENSI,
but so far there are no signs of significant impact on other activities.
Discussion/evaluation
The main problem of ENSI seems to be the
lack of emphasis on development and change in school practice. Most
schools were using the MEIS-programme, but they did not recognise development
as the aim of the project. They were familiar with energy saving programmes,
and EE-projects, but did not focus on ENSI as a means for school development.
Consequently, they applied MEIS as an ordinary EE-project, continuing
"business as usual".
Also, the project, both as a "ordinary
EE-project" and as a school development project, relied on the involvement
of an especially committed or dedicated person, a headmaster, teacher
or member of the technical staff who was strongly dedicated to the project,
whether it was MEIS or ENSI. Therefore, the reason why five schools dropped
out of the project, was "lack of dedicated persons to initiate and/or
lead the project", as one headmaster reported back.
The conclusion at this first stage would
therefore be that most schools were already involved in "school development"
through EE-projects, but did not recognise or understand ENSI as a means
for such development. But by becoming aware of this "problem",
they wanted to approach MEIS again, emphasising the development aspect.
Research tasks in the second stage
From being an "external evaluation group"
the researchers are now taking a more active part in the schools' ENSI
project by participating in the discussion about why and how ENSI might
be understood and what policies to adopt to be able to fulfill the aims
of the project.
The next stage in the evalution will be
to analyse
- the communication between the Ministry
and the schools concerning ENSI
- the schools' understanding of ENSI
- the barriers that prevent this EE-project
from becoming "mainstream"
- what kind of benefits there might be
in a development of external/internal cooperation for the school
- how the different schools understand
"school development" and what interests they have in taking
part in such a development
- what pupils regard as important in this
particular EE-project
This will be done through interviews and
discussions at the various schools and a more in-depth questionnarie in
spring 2000. The research group will also take part in workshops with
involved teachers and headmasters. A final report will be made late autumn
2000.
Tønsberg, Norway, Dec. 1999
Ø. Wistrøm, S. Bjørshol,
I. Vinje
  
Stig Bjørshol,
Inge Vinje, Øyvind Wistrøm:
Evaluering av ENSI 3 : Miljølære og skoleutvikling : Første rapport
Copyright ©
2000 forfatterne
Høgskolen
i Vestfold
|